Best Italian Restaurants in Belize City
Curated guide featuring 7 outstanding restaurants, all rated 4.5+ stars
Belize City might not be the first place that comes to mind when craving authentic Italian cuisine, but this vibrant Caribbean hub has quietly cultivated an impressive collection of Italian-inspired eateries that rival destinations far more famous for their pasta and pizza. What makes the Italian dining scene here truly special is how these restaurants blend Mediterranean traditions with Caribbean flair, often incorporating fresh local seafood and tropical ingredients that give classic dishes an unexpected twist. The relaxed, oceanside atmosphere adds another layer of magic – imagine savoring perfectly al dente pasta while Caribbean breezes drift through open-air dining rooms.
This guide showcases nine exceptional Italian restaurants in Belize City, each boasting ratings of 4.5 stars or higher from hundreds of satisfied diners. We've gathered spots ranging from intimate family-run trattorias to lively waterfront establishments, all united by their commitment to quality ingredients and genuine hospitality. Whether you're seeking a romantic dinner overlooking the water, a casual lunch with friends, or simply the best wood-fired pizza in town, these top-rated restaurants represent the cream of the crop in Belize City's Italian dining scene. With an impressive average rating of 4.7 stars across all featured establishments, you can dine with confidence at any of these carefully selected spots.
Featured Restaurants
Midtown Restaurant & Bar
A beloved gathering spot in Belize City, Midtown Restaurant & Bar draws both locals and travelers with its welcoming atmosphere and diverse menu that caters to varied tastes. With over 1,100 glowing reviews and a solid 4.5-star rating, diners consistently praise the quality food, friendly service, and comfortable setting that makes it perfect for both casual meals and special occasions. Arrive early during peak dining hours to snag a good table, as this popular spot fills up quickly with repeat customers who know they'll get reliable, satisfying meals at reasonable prices.
Old River Bar & Grill
Perched along the waterfront, Old River Bar & Grill has earned its stellar reputation among both locals and visitors with a diverse menu that caters to varied tastes in a relaxed, welcoming atmosphere. With nearly 400 glowing reviews and a 4.7-star rating, travelers consistently praise the quality and value at this mid-range gem on Regent Street. Arrive early for dinner to snag a table with river views, and don't hesitate to ask the friendly staff for their daily specials or house favorites.
Smokeez Seaside Restaurant & Bar
Perched along Seashore Drive, Smokeez Seaside Restaurant & Bar delivers exactly what its name promises: cold drinks and satisfying eats with ocean breezes just steps away. With an impressive 4.6-star rating from over 300 reviews, travelers consistently praise this laid-back spot for its welcoming vibe and reliable quality that keeps both locals and visitors coming back. Arrive during golden hour to snag a waterside seat and soak in the sunset views while enjoying the relaxed Caribbean atmosphere.
Taka Kitchen
Perched at a prime waterfront corner, Taka Kitchen has earned its stellar 4.8-star reputation from over 200 travelers who rave about its diverse menu that showcases multiple cuisines in one welcoming spot. The high ratings suggest consistently excellent food and service, making it a reliable choice whether you're craving local Belizean flavors or international comfort food. With its convenient Marine Parade location and mid-range prices, it's perfect for a relaxed lunch with ocean views or a satisfying dinner after exploring downtown Belize City.
Garage Seafood and Steakhouse San Pedro Belize
Located just a mile north of San Pedro, Garage Seafood and Steakhouse delivers exactly what its name promises with a laid-back island atmosphere that keeps both locals and tourists coming back. With an impressive 4.8-star rating from over 200 reviews, diners consistently praise the fresh seafood and quality steaks at reasonable prices for the area. Arrive early during peak season to snag a table, as this popular spot fills up quickly with travelers who've heard about its winning combination of great food and welcoming vibe.
Gonzalo and The Princess
This beloved San Pedro gem has earned an impressive 4.9-star rating from over 160 diners who rave about its welcoming atmosphere and diverse menu that showcases various cuisines. The consistently high praise suggests you'll find both quality food and genuine hospitality, making it a reliable choice whether you're craving local flavors or international dishes. Given its popularity and mid-range pricing, consider making a reservation or arriving early to secure a spot at this traveler favorite.
La Fonda De Nilo
La Fonda De Nilo has earned its stellar 4.6-star reputation among both locals and travelers in San Pedro with its welcoming atmosphere and diverse menu that caters to various tastes. With over 168 glowing reviews, diners consistently praise this Flamboyant Street gem for delivering quality meals at reasonable prices in a laid-back island setting. Arrive early during peak season to snag a table at this popular spot, where the friendly service makes you feel like part of the family.
Culinary Experiences in Belize City
Discover food tours, cooking classes, and unique dining experiences